1860 census shows the correct family members and says that they both were born in VA or present day West VA, approx. 1809. I am unable to find anything for either, including any census records as to where they were from the time of their marriage, until the census of 1860. Rachel was at that time married to Elijah Coffelt 19 Dec 1856 in Putnam Co IN
There are many George Carpenters and Elizabeth Carpenters, many stayed in PA, some moved to Kentucky and MO. But I am sure his birth was in VA and then he moved westward to IN, OH and family settled in IA.